Telescopic Eye Collection Telescopic Original Mascara Waterproof Black

Tough I loved how it looked when it was applied & it looked great...then came the disappointments. First note this is waterproof mascara. I was outside in the wind and I ended up looking like a raccoon. So on that note so much for waterproof in wind conditions??? I don't understand this? My 2nd, is the biggy. It was noted this mascara to be easy to remove from your lashes. This is NOT easy to remove at ALL! Even after the wind made me look l like a raccoon :/ I used eye makeup remover pads and had to scrub & scrub & scrub and it still wood not come off completely. This meant treating my eyelashes harshly & my delicate eye area as well. Not what anyone desires. Then after failing to get off after multiple attempts with the eye make up remover , I washed & rubbed with soap and water causing much harsher removal than anyone should be doing to clean their eye lashes or eye area making pulling and etc. I had to spend so much time & effort trying to remove this mascara it was unbelievable! I can't imagine what shape my eye lashes & eye tissue area would end up if I continued to use daily just trying to remove in such a harsh manner. Very disappointing. I have used Loreal products for Many many years and never had so much trouble removing waterproof mascara before in Loreal or other brands as well. You should not have to aggressively scrub you lashes or eye area ever its not good for them.

I love this mascara. It’s my day to day it is so lengthening and makes my lashes stand up all day

I really really dislike this mascara -- especially the "brush" -- and I use that term loosely.( I wish I could find Voluminous waterproof very black in stores. What has happened?) I bought two this type and I won't even open the second one. I guess I'll try Panorama since there is a waterproof version AND it actually has a brush. I've been using Voluminous for probably 20 years ... or more?

This mascara was horrible in my opinion. It made it look like some of my lashes were way shorter than they normally are with no mascara on. It clumped, made my eyes extremely dry and itchy, and felt very heavy on. I never wrote reviews and typically love L’Oreal but this one is unwearable for me.

I bought the waterproof version of this mascara for a wedding since I really loved the non-waterproof, but wanted to make sure I had longer use with it. However, after 2 consecutive days using this mascara (and fully removing all product after both uses), I have developed a chemical burn or severe reaction across both eyelids, and they have been very uncomfortable to the touch. They started out by being puffy, and have now decreased in swelling, but have very scaly/dry/irritated skin along my lash line. I have never had an issue with the other formula, so I am not sure what happened with this one.

Absolutely love this mascara. I love the brush. It coats the lashes really well and really lifts up the lashes to make them look longer and full I’ve used a lot of different mascaras and this by far is the best one. I really hope this particular mascara will be staying for a long time