Informations produit
Brosse incurvée. Des cils 5X plus épais. Résiste aux grumeaux.
Le mascara Voluminous® Original constructeur de volume présente une formule unique qui résiste aux grumeaux, adoucit les cils et leur donne 5X leur épaisseur naturelle, pour un look spectaculaire. La brosse volumisante incurvée épaissit les cils de manière lisse et uniforme et les rend doux, sans que le mascara ne s'écaille, ne coule ou ne forme de paquets.
Testé sous contrôle ophtalmologique et soumis à des tests d'allergies.
Convient aux yeux sensibles et aux porteurs de lentilles de contact.
Sans parfum.
Sans paquets.
Ingrédients
AQUA / WATER / EAU • PARAFFIN • CYCLOPENTASILOXANE • CERA ALBA / BEESWAX / CIRE D'ABEILLE • STEARIC ACID • TRIETHANOLAMINE • ACACIA / ACACIA SENEGAL GUM • CARNAUBA / CARNAUBA WAX / CIRE DE CARNAUBA • PALMITIC ACID • DIMETHICONOL • HYDROXYETHYLCELLULOSE • PANTHENOL • IMIDAZOLIDINYL UREA • SODIUM POLYMETHACRYLATE • METHYLPARABEN • PEG/PPG-17/18 DIMETHICONE • 2-OLEAMIDO-1,3-OCTADECANEDIOL • PROPYLPARABEN • SIMETHICONE • BHT • POLYQUATERNIUM-10
[+/- MAY CONTAIN: CI 77492, CI 77499, CI 77491 / IRON OXIDES • CI 77007 / ULTRAMARINES • CI 77891 / TITANIUM DIOXIDE • CI 77266 / BLACK 2 • MICA • CI 75470 / CARMINE • CI 77510 / FERRIC FERROCYANIDE • CI 77288 / CHROMIUM OXIDE GREENS • CI 77289 / CHROMIUM HYDROXIDE GREEN]
Évaluations
Notes moyennes des clients
Qualité du produit, 2.0 sur 5
Rapport qualité-prix du produit, 2.3 sur 5
Images et vidéos du client
Filtrer les avis
Cote
Paramètre régional
1 to 8 sur 47 commentaire
1 – 8 sur 47 commentaire
Les plus récents
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Horrible new formula; they changed more than the o
il y a 6 mois
I’ve used the curved brush voluminous for over 20 years; I could fall asleep with my makeup on and apply a new layer the next day; no longer can do that as it sticks my lashes together in a very ugly way; also, I’ve always been able to use my Cerave bar soap to wash my face and it would wash the mascara off wonderfully; now I wash my face three times a day still being able to feel the hard clumps of mascara sticking to my lashes; got out of the shower and had mascara clumps under my eyes; and lashes falling out. This new formula is HORRIBLE.
Traduire avec Google
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 6 mois
LeCare
Hi Kdl82. there! Thank you for giving Mascara Curved Brush a try. We are sorry to hear that it did not meet your expectations. We appreciate your feedback because the opinion of our consumers are important to us. We will be sharing your feedback with the rest of our team and hope that in the near future we create a product that better suits your needs.
2 étoile(s) sur 5.
Why, oh why do you ruin the ABSOLUTE BEST product?
il y a 7 mois
I have used this particular mascara for decades. I’ve tried every mascara on the market, no exaggeration, because I know/knew eventually you would try to “improve” it or discontinue it. But I always come back to this one. I buy 10 tubes at a time so I don’t run out. Voluminous black curved brush. Excellent wear, tons of compliments. Something has changed. For goodness sake, GO BACK to what I and others have worn every single day for decades. If I wanted something different, I’d buy something different.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 7 mois
LeCare
Hi Workedforwhatihave. Thank you for reaching out to L'Oreal and sharing your comments on the Voluminous Curved Brush Mascara. We're sorry to hear you're not pleased with the formula change. Feedback from our consumers is very important to us and helps us improve all of our products! We appreciate you sharing your experience. We will be passing on your comments to others in our team. We hope you continue using our products!
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Too much glue
il y a 9 mois
All my lashes stick together. Impossible to remove. Too much glue.
Traduire avec GoogleNon, Je ne recommande pas ce produit.
Utile?
Qualité du produit, 1.0 sur 5
Rapport qualité-prix du produit, 1.0 sur 5
Réponse de L'Oreal Paris Canada :
il y a 9 mois
BEC
Thank you for sharing your feedback on our Voluminous Curved Brush Mascara Black. We understand how frustrating it is when you try out a new product and it does not perform the way you expect it to. As consumers ourselves, we understand how frustrating this can be and we will be sure to share this feedback with our team. We recommend trying a waterproof eye makeup remover while removing this mascara's formula. We hope you can use our products with great satisfaction in the future!
2 étoile(s) sur 5.
The brush gets too full when pulled out of tube
il y a 9 mois
Did the packaging change? The brush comes out over loaded with mascara now. Wiping off the tip isn't enough, it's goopy all over the brush. I checked inside to see if the inner ring that makes sure the brush isn't over full was missing but it's there.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 9 mois
LeCare
Hi Shopper. Thank you so much for sharing your experience with our Mascara Curved Brush Black Brown. We are sorry to hear that you did not see the results you have come to expect with this mascara The iconic brush is unchanged, you should see the same length and separation you always did. We will share this feedback with the rest of our team, and we hope that you will continue to explore and use our products !
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
BIG Mistake
il y a un an
This is NOW horrible mascara. The original was the best. I can’t understand why the change? Also, I posted a review several months ago, and it is no where to be found. In addition, reviews I read previously aren’t there anymore? There are MANY more negative reviews. Instead of editing/deleting reviews, how about go find/produce the original formula and then you won’t have to worry about deleting negative reviews.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
LeCare
Hi Althor. there ! Thank you so much for sharing your experience with our Mascara Curved Brush. We are sorry to hear that this product did not meet your expectations. Feedback from our consumers are important and helps us improve our products. We will be sharing your comments with our team.
2 étoile(s) sur 5.
Not worth buying
il y a un an
New formula says it lasts for 24 hours. I find it is difficult to remove with soap and water and with makeup remover. It also clumps and smears terribly. I have used the previous version for years, loved it, but am now looking at other brands. If you can tell me which of your mascaras are like the older version, I would eagerly try that.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
LeCare
Hello Nolan55, we appreciate you reaching out about Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We understand how frustrating it is when a mascara does not provide you with the results you had expected. Your input is instrumental in helping us improve our brand and deliver products that meet your needs and desires. Your feedback is valuable, and we appreciate you taking the time to share it with us.
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Voluminous mascara new formula is CRAP
il y a un an
New formula for voluminous mascara is garbage. So disappointed. Used the original formula for 25+ years.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hello Logan ! Thank you for giving our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush a try ! We apologize that you did not end up liking this product and appreciate you sharing your experience ! Feedback from our consumers is very important to us and helps us improve all of our products ! We appreciate the opportunity to be of service and hope you will continue to explore our products and find your favorite!
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Allergy reaction for a new formula
il y a un an
I was using this mascara for several years. Last week I bought a new tube and it gave me a horrible allergy reaction. Can't use it and have to look for other options. Please, bring the old formula back.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hello AnnaTs. There! Thank you so much for sharing your experience with our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We are sorry to hear that this product did not meet your expectations. Feedback from our consumers are important and helps us improve our products. We would love to make this right please call our toll free number at 800 322 2036 MF9:00 am – 5:30 pm ET.
1 – 8 sur 47 commentaire
Évaluations
Notes moyennes des clients
Qualité du produit, 2.0 sur 5
Rapport qualité-prix du produit, 2.3 sur 5
Images et vidéos du client
Filtrer les avis
Cote
Paramètre régional
9 to 38 sur 47 commentaire
9 – 38 sur 47 commentaire
Les plus récents
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Bring back the old mascara!
il y a un an
The new formula is terrible. It clumps when trying to wash off and it’s a mess. My lashes don’t look as fill either. I’ve used this brand of mascara for 25 years. I sadly have to switch.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hi there Megcap, We wish you were seeing the results you were hoping for with the Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We want to understand what happened just as much as you do. While it is possible that minor changes have been made in the formula, the performance should meet or exceed previous results and may not be noticeable at all. If you would like to speak to us directly about your recent purchase, give us a call @ 800-322-2036 9 AM to 5:30 PM ET M – F
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
New Formula is Terrible
il y a un an
HATE this new formula! This was my tried and true mascara for 20+ years and I'm heartbroken to have to find a new option. Please change this back to the original formula for all of your loyal fans!!
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hi ath89! Thanks for reaching out to us regarding Voluminous Mascara. We're sorry that you are not happy with the current formula for this product. We will share your comments with our teams.
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Absolutely TERRIBLE
il y a un an
The new formula is TERRIBLE! I have been using this product for over 20 years! It has always been my favorite mascara! At first I thought it was a mistake and I got waterproof on accident, but it’s not! The washable mascara does not wash off! It makes your eyelashes break within just a couple days of use! I am so upset!!!!
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hello! We are sorry to hear about the experience you had with Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We would like to speak with you directly about it. Please give us a call at 800-322-2036, 9:00 am - 5:30 pm ET for assistance and provide the reference number 36586970. It would be helpful if you could have the product available when you call. Looking forward to speaking with you.
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
New formula is horrible
il y a un an
This new change to 11x is horrible I’ve been wearing the original for 25 years. The new one (not waterproof) will not come off. my eyelashes are coming off from trying to get it off. My lashes are not as thick as they were with the old formula. For this reason will be switching to another mascara line. Big mistake for tacking a good product and changing it. You are going to loose more customers with this new formula. So good bye after 25 years pass this along from the people who decided to botch the new mascara
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
L'Oreal Paris
Hello! We are sorry to hear about the experience you had with Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We would like to speak with you directly about it. Please give us a call at 800-322-2036, 9:00 am - 5:30 pm ET for assistance and provide the reference number 33513729. It would be helpful if you could have the product available when you call. Looking forward to speaking with you.
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Awful
il y a un an
This recently changed to a new formula and it’s awful, no more long thick lash, you can’t get it off even with baby oil. You took an amazing mascara and made it horrible. My lashes were long and thick, new formula short lashes and all clumped together. I’m so disappointed, please bring back the old formula.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hello Becky. Thank you for sharing your experience with our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We wish you were seeing the great results you should with your recent purchase! This mascara is formulated to resist clumping, soften and build lashes up to 5X their natural thickness. The Volume Maximizing Curved Brush matches the shape of your lashes to thicken lashes evenly and smoothly. If you would like to speak to us directly about your recent purchase, give us a call @ 800-322-2036 9 AM to 5:30 PM ET M – F
2 étoile(s) sur 5.
Not what it says
il y a un an
This mascara stinks. That’s a pleasant word for not good. I thought I had picked up waterproof and maybe I did it clumped on and it wouldn’t come off at the end of the day even with mascara remover. I don’t know if they had a bad batch or what but it was, bad on my eyelashes, thin them out badly
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
L'Oreal Paris
Hello! We are sorry to hear about the experience you had with Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We would like to speak with you directly about it. Please give us a call at 800-322-2036, 9:00 am - 5:30 pm ET for assistance and provide the reference number 33064864. It would be helpful if you could have the product available when you call. Looking forward to speaking with you
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
This makes me sad!
il y a un an
This has been my favorite for YEARS. Yesterday I tried the newer formula & it seems to be waterproof! I can't get it off without ripping out my lashes....it does not say waterproof so I don't get it. Very sad, now I have to change my mascara.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hello Mrs Brown. There! Thanks for reaching out and sharing your experience with us regarding our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. Feedback from our consumers is very important to us and helps us improve all of our products! We are sorry to hear that this product did not leave you with the results in which you expected. We thank you for giving this product a try as we will be passing on your comments to others in our team!
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Yuck
il y a un an
Probably the worse L’Oréal mascara I’ve ever used. It clumps, it’s hard to get off and just looks bad. I’ll go back to my old L’Oréal mascara
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a un an
Consumer Care Center
Hello there! We are so glad you got a chance to try our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush and are sad to hear it was not the right fit for you. As consumers ourselves we completely understand and value your feedback as it serves as a tool to enhance our product and ensure customer satisfaction as a whole. Please rest assured that your comments have been passed along to the rest of our team and hope that you give our other products a try! XOXO
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
New formula misses the mark
il y a 2 ans
This used to be my favorite mascara. Black with curbed brush. I’ve used it for 20 years and always got compliments and people thought they were fake they looked so good. There was no flaking or clumping and it removed easily. The new formula is terrible. It clumps my lashes and will not come off even with makeup remover. If there is not a way to get the old formula back, I will have to switch. Please let me know how to get the old formula without the gold band on the packaging.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 2 ans
L'Oreal Paris
Hello there! We are very sorry to hear about the experience you had with our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We want you to know that we are constantly striving to improve the performance of our products. We appreciate your feedback and we will be sharing this with our team.
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Not for me
il y a 2 ans
Despite the use of use, the next day after use, I experienced significant eye irritation
Traduire avec Google
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 2 ans
Consumer Care Center
Hello Mom141! Thank you for reaching out. We are sorry to hear of your experience Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We would like to speak with you directly about it. Please give us a call M-F 9:00 am – 5:30 pm ET at 800-322-2036 and provide us with the reference number 32440302. We look forward to speaking with you!
2 étoile(s) sur 5.
Great for 25 years, now POOR!
il y a 2 ans
This formula seems to have changed, but not for the better. Where can I get the original formula that I’ve used since 1996?? Clumps, not washable, eyelashes rip out when washing etc. I can tell the tube design has slightly changed but none of this is indicated on the package! What has gone wrong here?
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
3 étoile(s) sur 5.
Miss the Old Formula
il y a 2 ans
I echo people's recent concerns about the formula of this product. I have been using this mascara for 10+ years and have loved it. Please go back to the previous formula; it was soft to the touch and a better look for volume. The current formula is too wet and doesn't even stick to the brush well, let alone my eyelashes. Overall, it looks/feels more like a Lash Blast formula, not the Voluminous one. I'm currently on the hunt to replace this mascara, which was my favorite for so many years.
Traduire avec GoogleAffiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 2 ans
Mugler
Hello DunawayCL! Thank you for giving our Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush a try! We apologize that you did not end up liking this product and appreciate you sharing your experience! Feedback from our consumers is very important to us and helps us improve all of our products! We appreciate the opportunity to be of service and hope you will continue to use our products with complete confidence and satisfaction!
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 2 ans
Mugler
Hi there! Thank you for your feedback on the Voluminous Mascara Curved Brush. We know that this is frustrating, and we will share this information with our distribution partners. We thank you for your feedback and we hope that you will continue to explore our products in the future.
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 5 ans
I've been using this product for over 20 years and am constantly getting comments about my eyelashes. I love it!!!
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Utile?
Qualité du produit, 5.0 sur 5
Rapport qualité-prix du produit, 5.0 sur 5
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Difficile à enlever
il y a 5 ans
j'ai eu beaucoup plus de mal à nettoyer mon visage après avoir utiliser ce produit. Au lieu de disparaître grâce à un nettoyant pour yeux, il s'étend et on doit frotter pour enlever la majorité du mascara. Il en reste le lendemain au réveil et cause des rougeurs dû au frottage. Même résultat avec deux nettoyant de compagnies différentes.
Non, Je ne recommande pas ce produit.
Utile?
Qualité du produit, 1.0 sur 5
Rapport qualité-prix du produit, 2.0 sur 5
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
Love the curved brush!
il y a 7 ans
This is my favorite mascara. It goes on easily, stays on all day without flaking, and comes off when I want it to.
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
Favorite Mascara and Brush!!!
il y a 7 ans
I have used the Voluminous mascara with the curved brush for years. It became hard to find near me for a while and and so I tried other brands ands brushes for awhile. Strongly disliking every other mascara I tried. Finally I found it again and I am super happy! My lashes are so full and thick and there is no clumping. I LLOVE LOVE LOVE this mascara!!!!
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
3 étoile(s) sur 5.
What happened to this mascara????
il y a 7 ans
I've been using this mascara (not the waterproof) for many years. Last few tubes I have noticed how difficult it is to take all of it off. I also have been finding clumps in the tube after the 2nd or 3rd use. I use a good mascara remover and still after I think I have gotten all of it off, I find some under my lower lashes. I don't put mascara on my lower lashes to begin with!!! HELP!!!
Traduire avec GoogleNon, Je ne recommande pas ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 7 ans
Consumer Care Center
Hi! Thank you for your feedback. We recommend trying our Eye Makeup Remover. This removes eye makeup instantly with a gentle, oil-free formula. We hope you check it out!
4 étoile(s) sur 5.
great formula!
il y a 7 ans
love the formula so much it makes my eyelashes big the only thing i dislike is the wand is sometimes a bit too curved
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
Love this mascara!
il y a 7 ans
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I first used this mascara a couple of years ago and have been using it since, it gives your lashes a push and fans them out making them look full and lush, almost giving a false lash look. Although when you first buy it the formula may be a bit runny, after a few uses it gets a great consistency.
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
Greate
il y a 7 ans
I love the volume that gives my eyelashes this product is very good.
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
1 étoile(s) sur 5.
Plein de grumeaux
il y a 7 ans
Je jette aux poubelles mon mascara Voluminous brosse courbée de l'Oréal Paris. Je n'ai jamais eu aussi pitoyable mascara qui met plein de grumeaux sur les cils. Inutilisable. Poubelle :-(
Non, Je ne recommande pas ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur Voluminous Curved Brush Mascara Noir Brun
Utile?
Qualité du produit, 1.0 sur 5
Rapport qualité-prix du produit, 1.0 sur 5
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
No clumps
il y a 8 ans
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love, love love this mascara, no matter what you do you will not have clumps. Your lashes look like your own only better
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
Curved for the Win
il y a 9 ans
The curved brush works as a double agent to be a mascara and eye lash curler. My eye lashes look bolder and longer than ever. I'll never go back!
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
2 étoile(s) sur 5.
Applicator brush
il y a 9 ans
This is great --but,the brush bends to the point that it will not go back in the tube. I bought 2 different times. Same results.
Traduire avec GoogleNon, Je ne recommande pas ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
Réponse de lorealparisusa.com :
il y a 9 ans
CCC
We are sorry to hear this and would love to help! Please call us @ 888.448.9617 M-F 9am-5:30pm EST and give the reference number #1854394. It would help to have the product with you when you call.
4 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 10 ans
THIS IS THE ONE MASCARA I KEEP GOING BACK TO. IVE TRIED ALOT OF DIFFERENT ONES BUT NOTHING GIVES U VOLUME LIKE VOLUMINOUS
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 12 ans
By far the best Mascara that I have used in years. Love the way it intensifies my lashes and last all day. I would recommend this product
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
4 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 12 ans
I've been using this for several years after my favorite Max Factor mascara was no longer available. This is a great drugstore mascara. It does what it says, makes lashes thicker in a single application of product. I always sweep a dry lash brush over my lashes after application to separate lashes. After it dries, I apply Voluminous Waterproof mascara to seal it. (My eyes will only tolerate waterproof mascara as a top coat, NOT directly on my lashes.) I remove with Clean Artiste.
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
4 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 12 ans
Really intense and dramatic mascara, however, it is a bit clumpy. But besides that, I love this product! Probably one of my favorite mascaras.
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
4 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 13 ans
It never clumps and makes lashes look longer and thicker. The only drawback is that after it has been used a little, I have to blot extra mascara off the end of the wand or it will clump the lashes
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
5 étoile(s) sur 5.
il y a 13 ans
I've been using this for years, but switched to Big Lash because I got a free deal. Not worth it. It ran too easily and didn't give me the volume of Voluminous. If you don't think this is the best, than you haven't tried any other.
Traduire avec GoogleOui, Je recommande ce produit.
Affiché initialement sur lorealparisusa.com
9 – 38 sur 47 commentaire
