Infallible Infallible Black Velvet Eyeliner Noir

This is by far the worst eyeliner I’ve ever bought! It has a weird velvet tip which makes it hard to apply. The liner itself smudges all over your eyelids very easily after it’s applied. I usually like L’oreal Products but this is just awful.

I just bought this have used twice and it isn't waterproof. Comes right off. I want a product that will last especially if they say it's waterproof.

Lasts all day doesn’t transfer to top lid and goes on smooth

This eyeliner can be applied thin or thick with the felt tip. I love that I can easily maneuver the lines into the width and shape that I desire. It goes on smoothly and flawlessly, yet is easily erased at the end of the day with remover wipes. I finally found an eyeliner that is fool-proof to apply and lasts all day.

Unfortunately I liked the way it worked for me, but in one month the product was dry. Even being a low price product, it doesn't worth to pay the price to use for a month. I don't know if it was only the one I bought, but I don't want to spend the money again to try...

I just wanna know what they were thinking when they created this eyeliner. The design is poor, no one is going to get a clean line with it. And the pigment? Non existent. But if you want an eyeliner that makes it look like you used a black crayon on your eyes, this is the one for you.

I wish I had read the reviews before purchasing this eyeliner. In my case, the liner went on easily but smudged badly within minutes. I applied a thin line at my upper lash line. Within minutes, I had smudges under my eyes - I cleaned it up and had the same thing happen again a few minutes later. I never applied the liner to my lower lash line so I'm not sure why there was so much product under my eye. My guess is that it doesn't dry fast enough. After several cleanups, it stayed put for the rest of the day...but I had to do a lot of touch ups to get there. I would not recommend and am not sure I want to go through the trouble of using it again. I'm usually pretty happy with Loreal but this was a big disappointment.

Bought yesterday. Smudged after 1 hour. Will not buy again. Expected more L'Oreal.